The Florida House of Representatives and Senate have sent
their latest bad idea to Governor Jeb Bush for signing. The ‘idea’ has been
dubbed the ‘Stand Your Ground’ bill. Rather than just tell you that this bill
is a bad idea, I thought I would explain, briefly, what the bill does, and why
it’s a step backward for Floridians…
‘Stand Your Ground’ allows Florida citizens to use deadly force when
defending themselves, rather than attempting to flee. This right extends beyond
the home, citizens who have a ‘reasonable’ belief they are in danger of bodily
harm or death are now permitted to use lethal force against their attacker in
any public or private setting. Just for the record, this bill includes all
forms of force including the use of a gun or other weapon.
It’s nice to see our culture of life coming into full
blossom. While I do not wish bodily harm on most individuals, I feel this bill
take it a step too far. Allowing people to kill at will on the basis of their
own personal assessment of the threat posed to them is preposterous, because
there is, without a doubt, someone who feels oddly threatened by the most benign
things. The fact that this is being offered as a necessary alternative to fleeing
is just irresponsible. I also don’t think that any law governing an individual’s
right the take the life of another human being should include the word ‘reasonable’.
See if you can follow this --- Lets say Joe has a serious fear of clowns (a
very common fear) and a street entertainer (dressed as a clown) approaches Joe to
pull a coin out of Joe’s ear --- I think you can begin to see how this is going
to play out. Forgiving the absurdity of the example, consider what little it
takes to make people feel threatened.
Hell, I was driving home one night and happened to make eye
contact with another motorist who proceeded to brandish a knife in my direction.
While I may have considered this display pathetic and Neanderthal-ish, I’m
certain that another person would consider that a threat of physical harm.
This bill will more than likely lead to a bevy on controversial
court cases in which individuals will be claiming that they felt threatened by
the individual they stabbed, shot, or beat to death. We’ll also see a re-birth
of lawless vigilantes out for a thrill. All the nonsense aside, is this really
the most important issue facing Floridians today?